Democratic Legitimacy of Science
Thu, Feb 20
|aki Bern
Join us on February 20 as we gather around Pizza to discuss: “Does science need democratic legitimacy?” Together with the philosophers T.Y. Branch and Hannah Hilligardt, we’ll reflect on how values shape scientific research, the importance of public participation, and what it means for trust in science.


Time & Location
Feb 20, 2025, 6:00 PM – 9:00 PM
aki Bern, Bern, Schweiz
About the event
Science is often viewed as objective and value-free, providing a neutral factual basis for decision-making. But how accurate is that picture? From deciding which research questions to pursue, to selecting methods, interpreting results, and communicating findings, societal and political values play a significant role in shaping science. For example, when investigating whether a substance is toxic or carcinogenic, scientists must set thresholds for what counts as “enough evidence.” Should they risk missing a harmful threat or wrongly flagging something safe? Such decisions cannot rely on scientific standards like accuracy alone.
If science is not value-free, this raises the question: which values can play a legitimate role in science? And should scientists alone make these decisions? One prominent position in philosophy of science argues that value judgments in science need to be democratically legitimized, so that they reflect the public interest or democratic aims. This might require more public participation in…
